Yes, you can use the old badges. But, I think, old badges needs some outline or thin shadow.
2 2013-01-24 04:19:28
Re: Poll: new app/dock icons (41 replies, posted in Development)
I think that it's wrong to use iOS-styled app icons on Mac OS X.
3 2012-12-30 01:55:36
Re: Poll: new app/dock icons (41 replies, posted in Development)
I think that textures for dark & light parts of 'C' must be different.
8 2012-12-23 06:07:53
Re: Poll: new app/dock icons (41 replies, posted in Development)
Ooh, it's Great! But looks too flat. It needs more 3-d effects. Can you publish the source?
(edit: removed quoting of previous post)
9 2012-11-21 08:58:44
Re: Poll: new app/dock icons (41 replies, posted in Development)
The new icon is too glossy and is not skeuomorphic, so it is not represents the Cog's minimalism and isn't fits to OS X environment.
When I see it, I remember 10 years old monstrous windows software )
11 2012-08-15 03:14:29
Re: Poll: new app/dock icons (41 replies, posted in Development)
Thanks for reply.
I never liked the ugly iTunes10 icon (and Mac App Store icon (and all other icons based on its template) 
I don't like this icons too, but I like color solution in icon #3 (green) 
Cog is an iTunes' "antipode", so it's a mistake to use iTunes-like icon for it 
In any case, big thanks for your work.
If you don't like something in my icons, tell me
14 2012-08-07 13:40:37
Re: Poll: new app/dock icons (41 replies, posted in Development)
Icons #3 is not bad, but...
Maybe I just really like my icons (#2) 
, but I do not like Jon Red's icons because they make Cog look like a iTunes...